?

Log in

Veronica Mars Debate

Recent Entries

Veronica Mars Debate

basementsongs

View

October 5th, 2006

Let's go S3!

Share
LoVe
So episode 1 of Season 3 has aired... where's the debate!?

I'll start... follow for nowCollapse )

July 4th, 2006

Okay people. I know it's been a long time since we've talked/debated. But I figure that we need to get this community back on track. Today, eyeshine and I discussed some topics from 2x22 (Not Pictured)

If you haven't seen this episode, I'm going to be nice and cut for spoilers. 




NOTE TO ALL MEMBERS: Feel free to post to this community anytime. You have a question about VM you want opinions to, post it. A pairing you're not sure would work, post it and see what people think. Just be sure to remember the tagging system. Use Tags! If you are posting a debate prompt on on Dick and Madison's relationship, use the tags "debate prompt" and "dick/madison"...if your post is about all or most of the Veronica Mars characters use "vm characters". If it is about the cast (such as Jason Dohring), use "vm cast"...Also, use your LJ username as a tag. If your username is not yet a tag, email me at wick001@sbcglobal.net and I will get the tag made for you! Other tags that can be used are "rant", "thoughts", or characters... "duncan", "lilly", "mac," etc. Thanks vm_debate members.

May 31st, 2006

Well, our May 28 to May 31topic of Troy Vandergraff and Dick Casablancas has come and gone. From May 31 to June 2 we will be talking about episode 1x21 (A Trip to the Dentist.) This episode is where Veronica finds out who "raped" her. Of course now we know there is more to the story than we orginally thought last season. So here's the big question...is this Dick's fault? Is he to blame in anyway? What he did, trying to drug Madison, is that right or wrong? Why have we so easily forgiven him? Or have we?  Is Veronica's rape(s) in anyway Madison's fault? Or Logan's (Logan did drug Duncan and feed Veronica body shots by the pool.) Dick, Cassidy, and Sean did feed her more shots and make her make out with Shelly. Casey Gant was there too...Can her rape be connected back to one of them? It was the drug (Liquid X or GHB) that was mixed with alcohol that made her black out. They fed her the alcohol. And lastly, is it okay what Duncan did? Leaving the Next morning?

May 28th, 2006

Okay, let's talk Troy Vandergraff. Did you like him? Personally, when we met him in 1x02, I thought, 'Oh great. Another Duncan.' The ghetto talk (where Duncan and Troy pretend to be ghetto) before the party in Credit Where Credit's Due was horrible. I definitely did not like the scene. But he is dead sexy. And he has a hint of cockiness. I liked that. I was a little surprised to find he was a psycho drug dealer. I loved the scene in 1x03 when Veronica went to his house after finding her mom was long gone. What did you think of the scene? Kind of cheesy? Yes. But I liked. For all of those who don't know what a debate prompt is, scroll down the community and check on out.  

Troy debate prompt. Have it out, fans!  

1. Troy is honestly a changed man.   

2. We'll see alot more of Troy next year because he'll be attending Heart.   

3. Troy and Lilly fucked...alot. On a boat. On a bench. Umm...anywhere.  

4. Troy dated Veronica was because he believed the rumors...that she was easy. 

5. Troy dated Veronica because she reminded him of Lilly.  

6. Had Troy not ran away, he would have played the poker game in 1x10 (An Echolls Family Christmas).

(no subject)

Share
Hello vm_debate members. I realize that the community is new and has had no order whatsoever. The rules have been somewhat unclear and posting has been random. 

Since we are in a summer hiatus of no Veronica Mars, we're going to have to debate and/or discuss old episodes because obviously a new episode isn't airing each week. Instead of randomly asking questions (which is great, but shouldn't our community have order?) I'd like to set up a system. From May 28 to May 31 you will only be allowed to post topics on...you guessed it, Troy Vandergraff and Dick Casablancas.  The posts can include anything about Dick or/and Troy. Please do not post anything that does not regard these two or it will be deleted. 

I'd like to take this opportunity to remind everybody about the tags. Use Tags! If you are posting a debate prompt on on Dick and Madison's relationship, use the tags "debate prompt" and "dick/madison"...if your post is about all or most of the Veronica Mars characters use "vm characters". If it is about the cast (such as Jason Dohring), use "vm cast"...Also, use your LJ username as a tag. If your username is not yet a tag, email me at wick001@sbcglobal.net and I will get the tag made for you!

Thank you,

Kayla

P.S. Let me know if you do not like this set-up. If it is not working for members, it will be changed.

May 26th, 2006

(no subject)

Share
This is basically just a debate prompt. I'll make a statement and you tell me what you think. These statements are random and I'm not claiming them to be true. 

1. Dick and Veronica could eventually have a relationship. 
2. Mac loved Cassidy. 
3. Logan would marry Veronica tomorrow if the opportunity presented itself. 
4. Dick and Madison never had sex. 
5. Wallace went to White Castle because he and Rashard got high that night. 
6. Lianne and Jake Kane are still having an affair.

May 25th, 2006

(no subject)

Share
So I wanted to get the debating off the ground and ask if there's anyone interested in being a mod at vm_debate

If so comment on this post with an email and I will get back to you ASAP! I'm pretty new at creating communities so hopefully someone will be able to help me pimp this one.

On the the debates, rants, thoughts...whatever you want to call them. 

Okay, let's start with Logan. I've heard alot of talk lately concerning why we forgave Dick. Well, it made me think, why did we forgive Logan? I mean, I certainly did. We meet him in season one and he's a total jackass, but somehow by the end of the season, we're fine with him and Veronica dating? Personally, I think it's because most of us get Logan. He's bitter. And when he's bitter he takes it out on the vunerable. He was bitter after Lilly died and Veronica was an easy target. As season one went on, I thought we felt for him more. We saw that abuse somehow (we're not sure how often, but we can assume) played a part in his life. We also saw him mother, who if he learned anything from, it was to drink away life. So here's this 17 year guy. The love of his life is dead. His best friend is non-existent (on pills that make him dull as ever). His once friend Veronica has "betrayed" him. His mother soon after kills herself. His father beats him, etc.

Does this give him reason to treat Veronica like shit? Not really. But can we forgive him and somewhat understand? Yes. 

Secondly, I've also heard alot of "OMG, I cannot believe it was Beaver. He always seemed so sweet."
 
Yeah, sure, we see a sweet side of Cassidy, but not always. Anyone remember in 1x20 when Dick and Beaver were harassing Veronica at her car. Beav says, "Yeah, you know you got a solid effort in the talent competition, but I'd like to see that car up on some cinder blocks."

And 2x17 when Beaver said to Mac, "Good luck getting laid."

Well, that's all for tonight...post your comments.

(no subject)

Share

Hello all. I got the idea for this community when fickle_dame posted rant on Dick Casablancas. killerspork33 and I commented on the post, disagreeing. It was cool to see other's opinions or ideas about the show. Even though we didn't agree, it was enjoyable to be able to get my point across. So, here's the community. Join and start posting your ideas on characters, what should have happened, why you liked/didn't like what happened, or anything involving Veronica Mars and it's cast. 

 

Thanks,

Kayla

Powered by LiveJournal.com